Should I Try To Convince My Insurance To Total Or Repair?

by bestpolicypartner » Mon Dec 18, 2017 06:02 pm

I have a 2008 Toyota Camry that's in... less than ideal condition. I live in Long Island, and spend most of my time in Brooklyn, New York.

It has 105,000 miles on it or so. I've owned it since I bought it in 2007 (although at one point the title was in a friend's name for a few years near the beginning of its life, while I only had a permit)

The interior is pretty dirty, and has a few small issues that are easily fix-up-able

The right side is scratched up, has a dent that makes the front right door have issues, and needs a new mirror

Both bumpers have dings, dents. A rear light has missing plexiglass on it.

I was recently in a small accident that caused the front left bumper to be dented, and has damaged the suspension / shocks / steering in some capacity (it thinks it's driving straight when the steering wheel is crooked, turning feels strange, some noises from the shocks)

My deductible is $200

The insurance assessor thought it might end up being totaled because of the suspension issues, but that given its (apparently low?) milage, it might end up being saved

Do I want it to be totaled? With a car in this condition, would I be able to get a reasonable amount back from it - enough to buy a used car in good enough condition to replace the car I've been driving?

Or should I try to convince the insurance adjustor not to total it?

Add your comment

Enter the characters shown in the image.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.