Esurance or GEICO

Hey guys, I've been trying to find the most affordable insurance provider. I've settled for two companies. Either Esurance or GEICO. I've noticed that more people seem to be leaning toward GEICO https://autovscarinsurance.com/esurance-vs-geico/. Which company offers cheaper rates for you? Also, what company is better in insurance claims? I'm open to other recommendations if you know of a better insurance company. Thanks in advance.